By clicking “Accept”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. View our Privacy Policy for more information.

What should you actually outsource when you outsource payroll?

Outsourcing payroll sounds as though it should remove payroll from the employer's to-do list. The provider runs the calculations, makes the required submissions, produces the reports and handles the regular processing that would otherwise happen in-house.

Much of the work can indeed move outside the organisation. Some of the decisions behind it cannot.

Consider an instruction to pay every employee a £500 bonus. A payroll provider can calculate and process the payment, but somebody within the business still needs to decide who should receive it, when it should be paid and whether any conditions apply.

The same distinction appears in less obvious situations. Payroll can apply an employer's sick pay policy, but an unclear policy may require the employer to decide how it applies to a particular case. A provider can calculate the effect of recovering an overpayment, but the decision to recover it, and the basis on which that happens, may involve considerations beyond the payroll calculation.

Outsourcing changes who performs the payroll work. It does not remove the need to know who is making the decisions that feed it.

Processing and deciding are different jobs

Most outsourced payroll arrangements involve a fairly clear body of regular work. Information is supplied, payroll is processed, checks are completed and agreed outputs are produced. The provider brings the systems, processes and payroll expertise needed to do that reliably.

The boundary becomes more visible when an instruction depends on something that has not yet been decided.

A manager may ask payroll not to pay a particular item because they believe the employee is not entitled to it. The provider might be able to explain how the payment would normally be treated and identify any payroll consequences, but that expertise does not necessarily make the provider responsible for determining the employee's entitlement.

This is not an argument for sending every decision back to the client. A well-designed service should establish which matters the provider is expected and authorised to handle without repeated approval. Routine decisions can then remain routine.

Problems arise when assumptions take the place of that clarity. The client assumes the provider will decide because payroll has been outsourced, while the provider assumes the client has already made the decision because an instruction has been received.

Expertise is part of the service

Keeping some decisions with the employer does not reduce the value of outsourcing. In many cases, the provider's expertise is what helps the employer make a better-informed decision.

A payroll professional can explain the technical treatment of a payment, identify information that is missing, challenge an instruction that appears inconsistent and describe the payroll consequences of the available options. They may also recognise that a question extends beyond payroll and needs input from somebody with different expertise or authority.

That is different from simply refusing to proceed whenever an instruction is imperfect. Good outsourced payroll should reduce the client's administrative burden, not create a new layer of unnecessary approvals. The skill lies in knowing which matters can be dealt with within the agreed service and which need the employer's involvement.

Clear boundaries make outsourcing easier

The best outsourcing relationships do not remove the employer from payroll; they make it clearer where the employer needs to remain involved.

That clarity can be established through the service agreement, agreed processes and the practical way the relationship operates. The detail will vary between organisations, and a provider may have authority to resolve certain routine matters for one client that require approval from another. What matters is that both sides understand the arrangement.

When responsibilities are clear, the provider can get on with the work it has been engaged to perform without seeking unnecessary approval. The employer knows which decisions still require its attention, and unusual situations have somewhere appropriate to go when they arise.

It also makes challenge easier. A provider that receives an instruction outside the agreed boundary can ask for the decision it needs without appearing obstructive, while the client can expect the provider to deal confidently with matters that are properly within its remit.

Outsourcing without stepping away

A business should expect outsourcing payroll to remove a substantial amount of work. Otherwise there would be little point in doing it.

What it should not expect is for every responsibility connected with paying people to disappear with that work. Employment decisions, organisational policies and appropriate authorisations still need an owner, even when their consequences are processed elsewhere.

A good provider takes responsibility for the service it has agreed to deliver and brings expertise that helps the client deal with the payroll consequences of its decisions. A good client gives the provider the information and authority it needs while remaining involved where decisions properly belong to the business.

That balance is not a limitation of outsourcing. It is what allows the relationship to work without either side having to guess where its responsibility begins.

‍

Ready To BeePayWise?

Let’s make your payroll the sweetest, calmest part of your month. Book a hive chat for a no-strings mini-diagnostic, or drop us a message and we’ll buzz right back.